automailed: (what to do... what to do...)
Edward Elric ([personal profile] automailed) wrote2011-10-03 01:20 am

[Voice (morning) / Action (evening)]

[Voice - Locked from Al, Winry, Gracia, and Elicia]

This might seem like a weird question, but I need to ask.

A lot of people - kids, even - act like they're fine with death and killing. The draft taught me that much. And around here dying doesn't even seem to matter because you just come back anyway. Is that what makes it- [Not okay, he can't say okay, it's not okay] ...more acceptable? Or is it something you're used to? And if it was someone else's life at risk, more than just your own, would that-

[...Dammit, this is probably coming out all wrong. But talking to Al back in the hospital had really gotten him thinking, probably too much, and... maybe he can't really understand something he's never experienced himself. Much like human transmutation- it sounds like a perfectly acceptable theory until the truth opens your eyes.]

...Nevermind. But if death is just temporary, is it really still death? And if it is, then... what's it like to die?

[He couldn't even kill the remnants of a Philosopher's Stone to save Ling. Using the souls of Xerxes for his own gain still haunts him to this day. Could he ever kill to save himself if his own death meant Al would die as well...?]

How can anyone be fine with taking the life of another person?


[So... it's the 3rd. Of October. And certain people from Amestris know the significance of that date. It's not exactly an anniversary that Edward or Alphonse celebrate, per se, but it's become an unspoken annual event to have a bonfire on that particular evening, and more often than not staying up all night. An unspoken promise of which neither will remind the other.

One more year gone. One more year of failure. But they're not about to give up, either.

They hadn't been able to have a fire the past year in Amestris, what with the Philosopher's Stone plot going on in the background and their lengthy separation after leaving Briggs, but here they find themselves in October once again, and the pair made a silent agreement to do it now. Thus, after dinner in the backyard of House #23, a fair-sized campfire will be burning all night, carefully watched and maintained by either one or both of the Elric brothers. They're mostly just doing your average campfire stuff- Edward is roasting hotdogs and marshmallows, Al watching the flames and tending to the loose sparks, the pair occasionally tossing out nostalgic stories. It's not an exclusive fire by any means, so bother at will.

And then, sometime around dawn, Edward will wander off to take a leak in the woods, and he won't be coming back. There'll be signs of a quiet scuffle and a flash of alchemic energy - and a collection of metal chips from a robot's arm being deconstructed - but nothing more to be found.]


[ooc: action tags (if any) can get Ed, Al, or both. If you have a preference just say so, otherwise we'll decide between the two of us or toss a coin |D)]
simplestgift: (Novel? What about Wellard?)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-05 03:44 am (UTC)(link)
They'll only recover and return to fight again. The problem is out of your hands but it's still there.
simplestgift: (Uneasy)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-05 03:54 am (UTC)(link)
You think they would choose to be prisoners rather than die?
simplestgift: (Colored True Neutral.)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-06 04:35 pm (UTC)(link)
You speak as if killing is the ultimate of all evils. I've been a prisoner of war, and I have died. Dying was easier.

[Scarier, but easier.]
simplestgift: (Carefully hidden thoughts.)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-07 03:31 pm (UTC)(link)
I lost everything when I was a prisoner, as well.
simplestgift: (It's an injustice.)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-08 03:54 pm (UTC)(link)
You don't get your life back. They've torn it all down and told you to get comfortable. Everything is gone. The person you were before is gone. Whatever life you have after that, it's one you built yourself, bit by bit, over the course of the years after and don't bloody tell me that's the world as it is and I should be grateful for it. That's what everyone says when they're not willing to keep it from happening to anyone else.
simplestgift: (Casual lieutenant)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-10 05:03 am (UTC)(link)
Have you ever been in prison?
simplestgift: (Lost in thought because I have to be)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-10 05:41 pm (UTC)(link)
Then believe me when I say death isn't the worst thing that can happen. I won't say it's good, but greater evils happen to the living. Sometimes I wonder if death exists so those evils may come to an end.
simplestgift: (Uneasy)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-12 04:17 pm (UTC)(link)
Why did you ask, then? About killing?
simplestgift: (Don't you understand?)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-13 04:26 am (UTC)(link)
It isn't a question of morality. Wanting to spare someone's life is never wrong. It's just a bit naive to think you can always accomplish it. While you're going about trying to capture someone who doesn't want to be captured, he's causing a great deal of harm to you and everyone around you, and so are the ones you're ignoring while trying to capture him. Many die so one might live. No one wants it to work that way.

[Hastily written.] But your morals should not change.
simplestgift: (Far more uncertain)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-14 04:09 pm (UTC)(link)
Of course you can. If it's between being who you are and causing less harm, there shouldn't be anything of a choice about it.
simplestgift: (Stiff upper lip.)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-15 09:44 pm (UTC)(link)
You're welcome.

[And, because this is completely anonymous...]

I think my views match yours more now than when I first started fighting, actually. Your values are not childish, and do not let anyone tell you they are.
simplestgift: (Neutral as Archie gets)

[written]

[personal profile] simplestgift 2011-10-18 12:20 am (UTC)(link)
You're welcome.